Roman has only been good when:
-He was protected in the Shield
-Had that one match with Bryan at Fastlane
-Is being beaten to hell by a heel
Other than that he's flopped as a face. Got no charisma, hasn't evolved his moveset at all. He's popular in the same sense that Cena is popular, except to a much lesser degree. He never had the honeymoon period where he was genuinely liked. He went directly from Shield to being jammed down our throats and immediately fell on his face.
this is next level bonkers to me
Don't get me wrong, if you feel that way you feel that way. I'm not gonna be the dude that says "WELL YOU'RE JUST WRONG! GIMMICK POSTER! GIMMICK POSTER! THESE AREN'T EVEN YOUR TRUE FEELINGS YOU'RE JUST TRYING TO MAKE ME ANGRYYYY!"
I just don't think that's right at all. He's getting reactions. Big ones. Strowman and Reigns, Reigns got the biggest reactions of the night, moreso than Bayley, in-ring. It's definitely working. Sure that doesn't say much about Payback's in-ring, but he's definitely getting the reactions. Whether it's hate or love, reactions are money. When someone draws no reaction, that's when they suck on all levels.
Like Carmella. And the deafening silence every time she comes to the ring. I always feel so bad for her. Anyway.
It's fine if you don't like Roman and I was painting with too broad a brush by insisting anyone that still hates him is under 5'3" and a Bryan stan. But man, I just don't see this Awful Roman that you're saying you see, because I hear the crowd reacting, and I watch the matches and enjoy them.