Carcassone
I played this and Catan, and the tutorial for Carcassone at least explained the game. Catan just did all these moves and was like, "See? This is how it works." and just left me bewildered, so I tossed that out straight away. Carcassone I understood pretty easy and quickly, I can see myself picking this up eventually.
this thread needs more carcassone love. <3 carcassone
I remember liking it when i tried it - just not enough to invest.
I am always looking for simple games like that for me and my girl to play - i showed her the demo and she said "no thanks" - that likely influenced my descision.