Huh. Well, I'm with you on TPM and AotC on that only liking key scenes thing, but I can't say I agree with you on RotS.
Yeah, but not only does Episode III feature such stilted dialogue, it directly takes a shit on the original trilogy with Goatse.cx-sized plot holes and direct references.
And the others didn't? Come on, even Phantom Menace dropped original trilogy lines left and right and let's not forget midochlorians or whatever and Anakin being a little kid. Also, the lack of Jar Jar in Revenge of the Sith almost makes up for all of the other shortcomings that movie has.
Vader's "NOOOOOOOOO!!" and Padme's death really killed the ending and Anakin's switch from "I am a Jedi!" to "Let's kill innocents WOOO!!!" was horrible...but at least it didn't have Jar Jar.
Except I don't even think The Phantom Menace is really that bad, it's just woefully mediocre and suffers from two awful performances (Jake Lloyd and Jar Jar Binks). Of all the prequels, it's the most original - and it actually looks like a film (not all the sets were blue screens).
What are you guys talking about? I don't remember any prequel trilogy. ???
they all sucked.
AIDS or cancer?they all sucked.
I would rather be subjected to any of those Star Wars movies than Twilight or High School Musical or Harry Potter or whatever the hell it is the kids watch these days.
AIDS or cancer?they all sucked.
I would rather be subjected to any of those Star Wars movies than Twilight or High School Musical or Harry Potter or whatever the hell it is the kids watch these days.
... but what exactly were your biggest problems with the RotS?
I would rather be subjected to any of those Star Wars movies than Twilight or High School Musical or Harry Potter or whatever the hell it is the kids watch these days.
idk man, they're both acted out by high school drama troupes.I would rather be subjected to any of those Star Wars movies than Twilight or High School Musical or Harry Potter or whatever the hell it is the kids watch these days.
The Harry Potter films aren't anywhere near that bad.
Dude, the Harry Potter series is much better than the Star Wars prequels. I can't believe anyone would even compare them.
what what what???Dude, the Harry Potter series is much better than the Star Wars prequels. I can't believe anyone would even compare them.
they both really really suck. i can't get through either movie because the acting is so universally terrible (with the exception of the HP teachers).
That's the most amazing thing about the prequels. Lucas was able to attract all these really good actors (even Christiansen was considered a good actor before these movies) and all people talk about is how bad the acting was.
You take out Jar Jar and limit the scenes with young anakin and TPM is a solid movie. Good action, the political story was decent (for a sci-fi movie), Darth Maul and Liam Neelson.
Jesus, leper Lesser Rumbler.
the phantom menance is the only star wars film to feature blood
Jesus, leper Lesser Rumbler.
For Star Wars PT hate?
Sorry I didn't read the OP, just thread title!
His review is almost as long as the movie! :o
I think the final answer is that TEEPO is just wrong.
So, basically what you're saying is, that The Phantom Menace killed your friend.
TPM was the last movie my friend saw in theaters before he died. :( We both saw it opening day. We went to the movies about every week and it was the last movie we saw together. He died just a few days later.
I've not watched the movie since not only because it sucks, but also because of this fact.
Fuck Phantom Menace.