the brands you're recommending aren't bad, but they're kind of ... expected? it never even occurred to me that people would drink anything cheaper/worse than your suggestions. like, do people actually drink Evan Williams? I actually own a bottle - I use it for reductions when I make steak au poivre. :D
that said, if I was at a party and saw those brands, I wouldn't blink twice - but I also wouldn't be impressed. being almost as old as drinky, I'm well past the point in my life where there's any danger of friends completely murdering bottles, so I hate keeping bad stuff around. at this point, I mix 12-year rum into my coke :lol
I cleaned up some shit tonight that we've accrued over the past few years: Malibu, Buttershots, Captain Morgan Private Stock, Praline (a sweet pecan liqueur), Christian Brothers (won't even cook with that. Added The Botanist, Coole Swan, Del Maguey Single Village, and 2 bottles of 10-year Tawny Port. Damn. but I am into tawny port right now.
spoiler (click to show/hide)
I actually kind of like the new Bacardi Oakheart for mixing :-[