The closure arguments on The Sopranos always struck me as weird.
ending spoilers
spoiler (click to show/hide)
It seems more like people just wanted to see Tony get his brains blown out, and anything else was unacceptable. S5 and 6 build up a war that Tony cannot win, and his recklessness and pathology/personality result in him getting killed.
In terms of the rest of the series...personally I thought it was all great. I'd argue each season has some type of closure, and a beginning/middle/end structure. S2 and S5 do this particularly well by introducing new characters (Richie Aprile and Tony B) with arcs that drove the seasons from beginning to end.
It's prob my second favorite show behind The Wire, and the most rewatchable show IMO.
ending spoilers
spoiler (click to show/hide)
It seems more like people just wanted to see Tony get his brains blown out, and anything else was unacceptable. S5 and 6 build up a war that Tony cannot win, and his recklessness and pathology/personality result in him getting killed.
spoiler (click to show/hide)
they said they'd always get lots of complaints when they'd have episodes where no one dies (which pissed them off to no end), so i can definitely see this. the other part is ofc that there's lots of viewers that aren't seeing anything deeper than what's immediately on the screen, but they fortunately never catered to those people anyways. when i finally saw the ending for myself i thought it was kind of silly how mad people got because it didn't feel that vague what they were going for.
anyways, now that i'm done with the show it's time to do the obvious: start over and watch it again. well that and play the Playstation 2 classic Sopranos: Road to Respect
(https://i.ytimg.com/vi/awwu4YvoyKs/maxresdefault.jpg)
spoiler (click to show/hide)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CJLDERGmDw
WTF
spoiler (click to show/hide)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40HPFGvZ4ro
"Fuck you ya fuckin' whoahr" :dead
spoiler (click to show/hide)
"My mudda's wake. Jesus Christ." :dead
s4 ending
Furio just left for good I guess and I'm super bummed. :( But at least he didn't get clipped...
Wtf at Ralph's death lol. Did Joey Pants just want out?
i don't think so. his arc was always building towards that conclusion anyway. shame tho because he was great in every scene he was in.
spoiler (click to show/hide)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5USEY1Oxkf0
s4 overall
I suppose but the same-episode "OH MY POOR SON!!!!" subplot out of nowhere, which directly leads to that later in the *same* episode, felt really last-minute from my perspective.
I'm not sure where they could have went with Ralph, but I was never sure of where they were going with him since his character was introduced anyways. He just kinda showed up at the start of s2 "Hey guys I'm here!" then dicked around with various subplots until "the big one" (Johnny Sack), then randomly gets clipped for debatably no reason smack in the middle of s4, with little lasting consequence for the rest of the season. "Oh I guess he died. Moving on..."
Like I already said, he's one of my fave chars, so that's clouding my judgment admittedly, but from a writing perspective it feels more "I need a way off this show, guys" than "This is something we've been meticulously building towards since Ralph's intro."