The Order - just finished this and I...really liked it. As a game I see all the complaints about not much meat to it, but as a story, it's pretty well directed, has good writing for a game, great cutscene direction, amazing art direction, excellent pacing, great voice acting, and a really good score. It's not perfect as a movie and it wouldn't win any oscars, but it'd be a summer action flick that's actually good and carries some style. Nice setting and worldview too. And the
spoiler (click to show/hide)
vampires
genuinely surprised me as I wasn't expecting that at all and it was a neat twist. I also liked the characterization of a good chunk of the main characters like Mallery, Jean-Luc and Lucan.
I can kind of see what they were going for and why they were probably surprised when it got panned. At times the game feels a lot like The Last of Us or Uncharted in the sections between combat where you walk through the story with npcs, climbing walls, jumping across things, put down ladders while the characters talk and the story plays out in a cinematic way. The difference and where they failed with The Order is that when there were gameplay bits they restricted the player far more than those other games in order to push the cinematic feel, including limiting the players weapons to only specific ones for each area (although this is more a gameplay balance style and I'm generally ok with it) and limiting player controls like the ability to crawl stealthy to only context specific sections (ps the stealth stage near the end is pretty horrible). Like if they wanted it to be received more like Uncharted/Last of Us, they should've give the player more freedom and fully consistent controls all the time.
Anyhow even though the ending leaves a lot of questions, I really liked the final lines and the last interactive cutscene. Been done before in a ton of games from Gungrave to MGS but this was one of the most stylish. Very nice cut to credits. In a lot of ways it's a very beautiful game and as someone who likes art through the video game medium, I had a real nice time, couldn't put it down and was throughly satisfied.
I think Ready at Dawn are still great developers and this doesn't mar their track record at all but I can understand that the game isn't for everyone.