Doesn't EvilBore in general hold the opinion that Resident Evil 5 is better than Dead Space, too?
0-2, there.
For the record, both Saint's Row and GTA's mission structure and assignment are balls. But while there may be more to do in Saint's Row, it's so pointless and juvenile that it ceases to be fun. Driving around in trucks and spraying manure on people? Truly, Postal-game material there, folks.
I like GTA's attention to detail, better humor (although not by much), and more fully realized setting.
You know how you said you didn't bother with any of the friend stuff in GTA4, Kranz? You don't have to bother with all those side missions in SR2, either.
In which case you're left with an ugly, badly animated GTA imitator, when you could be playing GTA.