What is wrong with the way that thread was self moderating itself... Yknow with discussion?
Think what you will of Jaffe and his comments I think the whole thread has reached stratospheric levels of dumb, and bannings like that don't really help. His hypothetical was an invitation to a ban, but only because gaf is an overly sensitive echo chamber shithole prone to bouts of hysteria. I can't say I'm surprised. Defamatory shit flinging and disingenuous reading comprehension is rife even among mods.
I see what you're saying about his emphasis on what the girl could have done devo, but I think that conversation can be had rather than kiboshed with ban hammers.