Darkwood is legit. I never finished it but these days when I get to like a dozen games a year, any game that actually gets me to play it for more than one session is solid or better.
It's pretty tough, which is why I didn't finish it since it requires a lot of commitment. It's also a bit repetitive in that you repeat day after day while exploring the same areas and pushing out and scavenging further. But the ambiance is fucking great. Up there with quality Silent Hill stuff. Very creepy, so play it in the dark.
Would like to finish it someday. I think when I dropped it I skimmed some playthroughs for the rest and seemed neat but also pretty hard and a lot of effort to get there and through it.
Know nothing about Toejam remake but will grab for free.