https://www.resetera.com/threads/ridley-scott-criticizes-superhero-films.514197/page-8#post-77039001
Astro:
The scripts in the top tier of MCU films are great, they do exactly what they need to do.
If they were "great" by the standards people like Scott are talking about, they'd not be as accessible and fun... these people are talking out of their arseholes.
Anecdote: Ridley Scott viewed my ex's post-production house to see if he'd use them for one of his films, and he put in a complaint that there was bird shit on the outside of the toilet window lol. The man is ridiculous.
Surejan.png
Their main point is also dumb
Fact is that superhero films are not written the same as award winning, best writing of all time, literary masterpiece level scripts and they would be worse off if they were. This idea that they are bad, or lesser because they do what they do is just posturing nonsense. Yeh, sure, there are some really bad superhero scripts, but there are many that are written really well in the style they are going for and it's pretty silly to just call them all "bad" or even just "lesser" without further elaboration.
"Their scripts are not any fucking good" remains egotistical nonsense that ignores their context.
Superhero movies didn't invent blockbuster entertainment, anything from JAWS to Indiana Jones, to Die Hard, to Alien itself *is* mass audience-aimed entertainment, not some esoteric piece of fine art.
You don't need to be bland to appeal to the mass and entertain.
And MCU movies aren't bad, in the sense that The Room is bad, or Birdemic is bad, they're finely crafted pieces of inoffensive entertainment, completely stripped of any personality.
They're not bad, they're bland and soulless.
Notice how many detractors of these movies didn't really have much of a problem with capeshit when they were represented by Burton's Batman (or Nolan's) Raimi's Spiderman, and so on.
It's not about being snobby towards superheroes, it's about being repulsed by completely insincere, toothless entertainment, saturating the market.