Bioshock 2 was overrated? I haven't heard anything about it since it released, I liked it okay.
Of the only three games I've played on that list, Mass Effect/Red Dead/Halo, all of his points are stupid. He says Reach is just like ODST, that RDR had tone deaf writing, and he even complains about the streamlining of the RPG gameplay in Mass Effect as though it was a bad thing.