I admittedly think P2P matchmaking (as the only MP option) for PC games is distinguished mentally-challenged, but that's a broad hatred not solely reserved for MW2 (other than the terribad precedent it sets for others, I really don't give a shit about MW2 using it because I never intended to buy it).
The MP being too "busy" with too much crap popping all over the screen is just a personal preference. I haven't been much of a COD MP fan for a while now (even COD W@W, which I enjoyed, got little play other than the Nazi Zombies mode). I can see where others like it, but it just isn't my thing, and I don't feel comfortable criticizing that.
We ragged on the single player for being stupid and aiming at the LCD because no one else was doing it. They are, in fact, praising the hell out of it where they would savage any other game with an equally stupid plot, which to me is akin to praising the writing on Full House while calling Facts of Life dumbed-down. And, after thinking about it, I don't think it's a troll. Watch the end credits (I forgot to mention this on the show) - they're set in a museum, with "exhibits" of scenes from the game which then come to life as the awestruck patrons gaze at the herculean feats on display. I read that as them taking all this overblown crap seriously. Ugh. Yeah, I hate it. It treats the player like an idiot. I feel totally comfortable criticizing that.
Again, since it seems to have gone willfully ignored here - we've spent quite a bit of time poking fun at other games in the past and received nothing but lulz in response, so I'm at a loss as to why this particular one seems to have poked a sensitive sore spot.
I also said I enjoyed playing a couple of the levels (the Oil Rig scene,for one), and Robert did praise Spec Ops, but that's also been ignored here.