I liked some old anime a whole lot, Captain Tylor, Galaxy Express 1999, and Ranma before it became extremely predictable. Can't get into the newer stuff, Bleach, Naruto, Samurai Champloo... none of it did it for me. FMA was pretty cool the little bit I saw of it. The worst was Eureka 7, that was the most emo shit I've ever seen.
My Japafag contribution:

2nd favorite game series ever.