Suggest plz. Looking for ones that feel good, are ticklers good? What about sheepskin or the vibrating ones?
It all depends on the person, but ticklers and vibrating ones are more "oh... that's... interesting, I guess" than "OMFG FUCK ME HARDER WITH THAT VIBRATING TICKLING THING ON YOUR SHAFT, YOU MONSTER". At least that's what I've found.
And I'm sure everyone knows this already, but if not: the trick with condoms and getting a "life-like" (read: moist, wet, warm) feeling is to put a drop or two of lube - like KY Silk is what I prefer, but feel free to experiment! - into the condom / onto your johnson before rolling the rubber on, and then maybe a drop or two on the outside of it so that your partner doesn't feel like they're fucking the finger from a rubber glove. You do that shit and it's pretty damn close to going bareback.