Finally, I found out the name of the movie. I had to watch more than a third of the 100 Scariest Moments in Movies (on Bravo), and it was number 22. I remember watching this show a long time ago and seeing this movie on it, but I could never remember the name.
Has anyone heard of this? A rather young Donald Sutherland is in it lol. Looks very good to me, although the ending is spoiled by the list.
trailer: