So were you just introduced to AI this season? This year is especially shitty thanks to that animatronic David Archeletta and his handlers. He's like the male version of JonBenet Ramsey and will no doubt die in a similar fashion - in his parents' basement with his panties around his ankles covered in semen. I know the show is total crap but I can't look away.
I do gotta admit to liking the American Idol Rewind epsiodes (old shows from seasons past run in syndication), especially now 'cause they're on season 2 - aka the Aiken years. I do this really bizarre sounding Clay Aiken impression - actually it's not so much like Clay but it's more like if Fred Schneider was auditioning for a part in Deliverance. Must hear to appreciate.