
I'm a fucking avid defender of his other films, including Lady in the Water, but this is... wow.

The acting and general direction is fucking terrible. It seriously looks like the actors had no idea how they should feel in this movie.
And oh Lord, the writing. The writing is worse than ever.
"It makes you kill yourself. I mean, just when I thought there couldn't be anymore evil in the world" and she says it all with a face that looks super serious and astonished but in a tone that sounds joking.