I can confirm that Payton is indeed the new creative director for Halo 4.
How I can confirm this? I'm not an insider of any sort, I'm a waiter/college student in flipping Alaska. I don't know anybody in the business personally. But I can confirm this story is all sorts of true.
About two weeks ago, I was working in my restaurant. It was a slow day, a rainy day, there weren't too many people coming in. My first customers for the day were a very nice middle-aged couple from Washington. Me, being an Alaska-born dude, and them, being outlanders, had lots of questions for me. I told them all I could about the local flora and fauna and such. Somehow, the topic of conversation segued into their son, of whom they were very, very proud. The Dad whips out his iphone and starts showing me pictures of his kid's workplace in Tokyo, "He works for Konami, have you heard of them?"
Anyways, to make a long story short. Ryan Payton's Dad can't keep a secret to save his life, he dialed up Ryan right then and there on his iphone and I had a brief conversation with him. With Payton's Dad already having spilt the beans about his son's future job, Ryan kinda confirmed it. "Its not a done deal yet, so don't go blabbing this around yet."
And so I haven't, until now.
and I know, this whole thing sounds fishy. A guy I know on the internet heard something from some guy, but I swear its the truth.
So there ya go.