Speaking from a non-member's POV, though, having Drinky's "Amsterdam" pic and the "Evilbore: No censors. No adds. No respect." motto seems to be giving GAF the one-two punch. They don't have access to the forum itself, so how are they supposed to know any different?
Sign up and find out. You just illustrated one of the other reasons it was selected -- its controversial. As far as I'm concerned, I haven't heard anyone go, "AN EVILORE HATE BOARD I AM NOT SIGNING UP FOR THAT?" If anything, they sign up to find out what the fuck it's about. If they don't like it, then they move on. If they do, they stay on.
Both the image and the name are an homage to Drinky and MAF's last words, not an assault on GAF. That'd be meaningless.
You have a policy about not talking about or hating on GAF, but the very name of the forum goes against it.
Not really. It's a term coined by MAF that doesn't describe the forum in general whatsoever. And you have a pic that Drinky posted that got him banned. If anything, these are about freedoms.
Is it against the very name to be necessarily neutral to GAF. Yeah, of course, because it stands for something it doesn't have.