Are you kidding me? Season 4 was basically a wacky keystone kops kind of thing, except that it was trying to come off as OMG SO SERIOUS! Marwais was the wacky villain who kept getting away to initiate OMG HIS NEXT VILE AND NEFARIOUS PLAN! Come on. S4 was crap.
Season 5 was pretty good for the most part, although it did stretch credulity with the "President is the villain" reveal. However, I will admit that that jumping the shark moment DID allow S5 to not have the typical mis-season lull.
There ya go. Season 5 was pretty constant.
And I can see that complaint for Season 4, although I thought that bringing in the Season 3 cast slower and throughout the season helped keep the plot more interesting then the villain.
Honestly, it's been so freaking long since I've seen any of Season 3 that I don't remember much of it. Which probably proves that it wasn't that great, but my reasons for remembering Season 4 are all BAD reasons. If it's a choice between forgettable and insulting my intelligence, I guess forgettable wins out.
And Fistfullofmetal, I'd rank 'em like this:
Season 1- Great
Season 2- Great at times
Season 3- Good
Season 4- Laughably dumb but still compelling television
Season 5- Pretty awesome at times but you could tell they were reaching the bottom of the "Bag o' Ideas"
Season 6- First four episodes were great- after that it was like getting fisted with a razored gauntlet and no lube
I guess my main problems with the show is that it really, really looks like they haven't learned anything about just recycling the same dumb old plots over and over again.
-Looks like there will be a power struggle and intrigue with the new President. Where have we seen that before?
-Looks like there will be moles within the power structures. Where have we seen that before?
-Looks like anyone Jack is close to will have bad things happen to them, except for maybe Chloe. But then again maybe her too. Where have we seen that before?
-Looks like someone close to Jack in the past will end up being central to the bad guys. Where have we seen that before?
It's like they don't even bother thinking up new ways to tell a story.