I hate that argument.
Favre was never very talented or very smart. He's not a very good football player. He's always had two things going for him- his arm and his durability, and that's about it. Keep in mind that he also holds the record for interceptions. I want to change the name to "throwing a Favre".
Explain how at age 38 he throws for over 4,100 yards with 28 touchdowns and completes something like 66% of his passes, yet he isn't very talented. Explain how a QB makes it as long as he did, with no real talent. He sucked down the stretch last year but he still did better than anyone thought he would.
Yeah, keep in mind that he holds the career interception record. Also keep in mind he has the career records for attempts, completions, yards, touchdowns. Also keep in mind he's top 5 in pass attempts per game and top 10 in pass yards per game. So why the fuck are people continually paying him millions of dollars and putting the ball in this hands so much every game if he only has an arm and a high pain tolerance

Maybe you're confusing Favre with guys who actually do suck aside from having rocket arms. Guys like Jeff George, Ryan Leaf, Akili Smith, Dan McGwire, Tim Couch, Andre Ware, JaMarcus Russell. I can go on and on.