For reference, I own C&C3 and Kane's Wrath on both PC and 360, and RA3 on 360. I don't play them. I don't think I got past the first couple of levels on the 360 versions, but I beat them both on PC. Halo Wars has controls that aren't shit, and are a lot more user friendly. Yeah, it doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a PC, but then again it also doesn't use a keyboard with near limitless binding ability. And maybe the graphics aren't what they could be on a PC, but I don't have anything against them.
Overall, I'm enjoying the single player. I'm enjoying the multiplayer. And I'm sure that, when I play it, I'll enjoy the co-op. If that doesn't constitute me calling the game good, what could? I mean, I realize that everyone has their own opinion, but I don't think it's deserving of all the hate, even if it's short. Story of CoD4 was pretty short too, imo, but people played the shit out of multiplayer. And I see that happening here, too. Not to mention the storyline in HW is really interesting so far.