For me, AOTY is between Merriweather Post Pavilion, It's Blitz!, No More Stories, Embryonic, Farm, and Hospice, leaning heavily toward MPP (suck it, haters/Willco). Honorable mentions to the new Cymbals Eat Guitars album and Phoenix's Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix.
That's probably more Pitchfork-alligned than anything BrandNew would list, but idc.