Disc 4 of Shenmue II is one of the greatest things in a game. Don't even care.
Incredible.
The differences between modern, urban living and the stark beauty of Langhuishan and Guilin's majestic natural rurality create a beautiful duality that I think Yu Suzuki was trying to express here. Spirit and nature vs speed, anger, and urban living. It's done to represent Ryo's state of mind, I feel. In both Hong Kong and Kowloon, Ryo does dangerous, self destructive, foolish things all in the name of finding vengeance. And then Guilin comes, and he starts to embrace the more spiritual side of martial arts, with the Tai Chi he learned from Guixiang and Jianmin. It's a beautiful way of touching on urban vs rural living, and I don't think any other game has perfectly encapsulated this nearly as well as Shenmue II. I don't think the game would resonate nearly as well if it had just ended at the rooftop, because then Ryo has learned nothing from his travels. In Guilin he truly learns here are other ways to live and it expands his world view. Starting the game angry and ending it with a sense of calm, questioning his revenge, is much more fitting I think. The fact that before you go to Guilin, you're coming from Kowloon - the very definition of urban decay - is no coincidence.


to

Ryo's transformation throughout the game, is incredible, natural character development. I don't think any game I've played has nearly topped the characterization of Ryo and his complexities nor his journey as a person. Ryo goes from rash boy, whose own ethics are starting to crumble and decay like the infrastructure of Kowloon, to a man who has saved himself through embracing sheer spirit and realizing the true nature of things. This isn't shown in full, but the end game definitely hints at it. The line between spirituality is not a thin in Shenmue 1 or II. The games - particularly II - are thick with Taoism, which I think is lost on the average western player. Xiuyin even quotes Daoism, expressing the will to see the "true nature of things".
Ryo goes from this:
To this:
And his character is transformed, continously, from I to the end of II.
I always get something different every time I play Shenmue II, and most particularly disc 4.
Disc 3 has so many highs itself.
Virtua Figthter RPG fully realized:
Practice, determination, and willpower: kung fu movie in game form fully realized:
Thank you for drinking Yu Suzuki's full cup of tea, Rufus. Most people haven't played Shenmue II nor given it a chance.

The only kung fu game

My favorite game ever.
