I'll be honest. I subscribed to GamePro back in the day. :'(
I did too. Although my excuse is that I was just a kid, and once I got to a more mature age (like 12, lol) renewal was stopped. I did enjoy it in the late 80s/early 90s, but nowhere NEAR as much as EGM (and later EGM2) and Gamefan. I liked Next Gen too, but seem to remember generally not agreeing with most of their reviews. I thought the N64 was a piece of steaming shit and loved the issue that proclaimed "Quality Over Quantity?
We don't think so" and showed pictures of crappy Midway games and the like.

Remember all the weird comics Gamepro used to have? The Adventures of Gamepro and the Flying Warriors comics? Weren't there Johnny Turbo propaganda comics in there too?
Best mag for a fighting game/animu fan back in the day was Game On! USA. It had import coverage, reviews, and serialized game manga like Samurai Shodown and Super Street Fighter II Cammy. It didn't last more than six issues. :'(