Thought wrong, I guess. Probably got a bit too over-enthusiastic since she didn't seem to be as unattractive or as dull/monotone as the other girls I've been on dates with, and we seemed to have a bit more in common than I have with most girls. But who knows? I'm still trying to deconstruct myself, trying to find out where I go wrong.
Been making a bit more progress with the girl at the gym, tho... saw her for the first time in a while and conversed for a bit. Found out she actually likes house and techno. (then again around here, "techno" is a generic catch-all term for edm, I highly doubt she listens to Richie Hawtin, Robert Hood, Jeff Mills, Ricardo, a bunch of guys named Marco, etc)