Funny thing is, as a kid, I absolutely refused to watch any sort of horror, figuring it would freak me out too badly (nightmares etc.). When I was finally convinced by a friend to watch some, I was shocked at how "mild" they were, not really scary or disturbing at all. Turns out my imagination was far worse than anything people tended to film, and I spent a lot of time catching up on what I'd been missing out
Flash forward and yeah, I don't really have any friends who enjoy horror as much as I do, and though I'm no connoisseur regarding the genre, I get burned constantly by friends who watch a flick, tell me it's "The Scariest/Goriest Movie of All Time", only to watch it and spend the next hour and a half rolling my eyes. The quest is ongoing for flicks or stories that will really creep me out or disturb me.