It's amazing. Ignore the crack smokers.
from my random bloggings .txt I keep around
Top10 of 2008
---
1. Burnout Paradise
2. Dead Space
3. Soma Bringer
4. Little Big Planet
5. Persona 4
6. Mirrors Edge
7. DMC4
8. MGS4
9. SSBB
10. Layton 2 / Tales of Vesperia
Yeah, I thought it was that good last year. I also played the heck out of the Island expansion for trophies and completition and pure fun while doing so. The game has SUCH good achievements/trophies/challenges. You get addicted to it and can play for dozens of hours and days in a row without every putting it down. The racing is fun, the NO LOADING is great, there is soooo much to do. Tons of secrets to explore and find. Great graphics, great racing, great cars.
Honestly if you're not an OCD completionist who loves getting rewarded for completing things, it might not be for you. I fall into that category so it's one of the best games this gen to me. The only other game this gen I think I like as much is Crackdown.