Life After Death is overrated. If you put the best songs (Kick in the Door, Hypnotize, Notorious Thugs, Sky's the Limit, etc) onto one album it would be great, but there's so much by-the-numbers filler. The "for the ladies" songs suck for the most part.
As a double album, All Eyes on Me totally shits on Life After Death, there is no competition. AEOM definitely has filler and bad "for the ladies songs" but overall it's impressive.