Oh come on...don't drop the "superior PC version" thing. ME2 and SC Conviction are console-exclusive and that's all that matters to 90% of gamers out there. The vast majority of sales for these games will be on consoles.
Anyway, Resistance 2 might have a high metacritic score but it had some of the biggest backlash I've ever seen for a game (rivaling GTA4). Pretty much everyone thinks it's a huge disappointment and actually worse than the first.
MAG is just awful, bro. I made a post in the MAG thread and don't feel like typing it out again.
And yeah, I forgot about Gears 3...another monster AAA exclusive for the Xgod 360.
Where did I claim the PC versions of those games are superior
? Sorry man, the whole "console exclusive" argument is just a very ignorant cop-out. Those games are not exclusive to a single gaming platform, period. You won't hear anyone with a Ps3 claiming The Agency and FF14 are exclusive to the Ps3, and if you do, then they're just as ignorant.
And please don't bring the very tired sales argument, the logic in that is completely flawed.
Oh I'm not claiming R2 is a great game (like I said, Modern Warfare is more my speed!) what I'm saying is if you consider it a turd, then the same can be said for Halo: ODST considering R2 holds a higher overall score than Halo: ODST . . . right ? I recall quite a significant backlash for ODST as well, something along the lines of "it should've just been DLC".
Like I said, MAG is very by-the-numbers. It's nowhere near the awfulness of FPS games such as Hour of Victory, but at the same time the only thing that stands out from the title is the amount of players supported.
Finally, of course GeOW 3 is a big exclusive! Only a fool would deny that. It won't be a day 1 purchase for me (the absolutely horrendous Multiplayer in GeOW2 completely soured the competitive aspect of the franchise), but I can see myself buying it for the single-player sometime down the line.
One last time; It's too early to call it
