We need pics to compares.
(Image removed from quote.)
(Image removed from quote.)
(Image removed from quote.)
(Image removed from quote.)
Raphael looks like a total femme, no surprise he's winning on this forum, Donatello looks like a douchebag, Michelangelo looks pretty cool, but I'd have to go Leonardo. That's a pretty epic beard he's got there.
It's always funny that Donatello was kind of thrown in there as the fourth turtle as the artist was a sculptor and wasn't even in the same Renaissance group as the other three who all lived at the same time and knew each other.
I'd have to say Michelangelo (the artist) can represent the vast majority of EB - emo, introverted, downer, didn't like Leonardo (it's ok, Leonardo didn't like him either - said Michelangelo's figures looked like sacks of nuts) OR Raphael (even got into a street fight with him), loves men and even depicts women to look like men. Leonardo was a friggin genius but couldn't get jack shit done because he was always running off to do something new. Curse of having too many good ideas.
They really should have switched Raphael and Michelangelo in the cartoon as Raphael was the young charismatic socialite. Probably the only straight one in that grouping too.

I think Raphael's School of Athens sums it up pretty well - he inserted the three high renaissance artists (himself included) into the fresco.

Going back on topic though I always related to Michaelangelo because he loved food.