I honestly don't see what's creepy about it. Aside from startselect and tehjaybo, none of us are voicing our fantasies about what "we'd do to them." There's nothing wrong with stating that they're both very attractive women, and some of us saying who the most attractive of the two is.
You see any of us parked in a van outside of a middle school, you can start calling us creepy. Unless we have kids that go to that school, but even then, 50% creepy.