better graphics is the ONLY reason to give a fuck about new consoles, controls have been perfect since dual analogs took over
I never understood the argument against better hardware. Like I'm supposed to feel bad I want a game to look great and run at a smooth frame rate at 1080P alongside it playing well. Look at Crysis 2. Sub 20 frame rate and sub 720P resolution on consoles when I'm playing it at 60fps at 1080P on PC. The smoother frame rate gives me a better experience and I want my consoles to give me this type of experience as well.
New tech is fine so long as it's done so in an intelligent manner. I can say for a fact that the ps3, for example was a horrible idea. It feels like as more technology comes into play, developers have to make sacrifices and since I'm consumer, that sucks ass for me. Many high budget games on the longer side of length have suffered. Final Fantasy XIII took 4-5 years to develop but has shit all for game content. It took multiple tries and getting used to the technology for Rockstar to learn from their mistakes with GTAIV and put out Red Dead Redemption, which came out years after GTAIV's release, finally making a game that rivals their past efforts in previous generations. Metal Gear Solid 4 is a cutscene fest, taking advantage of new tech while losing itself in its own shitty priorities.
Maybe it's just coincidental, but I find that new tech makes developers lose sight of what's important and often ruins shit that I personally enjoy. It takes Square Enix 4-5 years now to make a Final Fantasy. Maybe it's their development process. Maybe it's because they're fucking off their rocker. But the point is, with the amount of voice work, animations, textures, and locations it takes them 4-5 years to put out ONE hd Final Fantasy with gimped content.
That tells me that a. new technology is not always good and b. developer priorities shift with new technology due to a raise in production values resulting in less risk and more desire to get paid.
New technlogy is a wonderful, beautiful thing. But it can also be a curse. The amount of developers dying in the past five years is a testament of this.
We are just now getting into this generation after what, 5 years, and things are FINALLY getting good. If we had another generation start this year, we'd be back at square one, and who the hell wants that? I really think that there's a huge trade off here like Stoney said, but ultimately, it seems that if gaming continues to pursue the new tech approach it always has been deep in, gaming will turn into Hollywood where only a few strong, big studios control everything. Except there would likely be less experimentation than even Hollywood. And as a gamer, I really don't want that.