this is like me reducing persona 3 to "random dungeons and
simulator"
Now you're being silly.
Persona 3 has:
- considering a weekly schedule (I would plan out my schedule on a weekly basis while playing)
- slinks (I actually made out an an actual schedule -- on paper -- in regards to what slinks I would do, this makes for very involving play)
- considering and weighing options (do I go to the dungeon tonight or should I just work on s links/skills?)
- battles
- loot and preparing yourself for the dungeon
- persona fusion and gaining of as many persona as possible
- a specific game flow and order of things, an addictive "one more day" kick
- quests via the velvet room with Elizabeth
and more. It's a game with a lot of variety in terms of content.
FF13 has:
- battles
- marks <--- battles
- no semblance of dungeon design, not that P3 did either, but it did have the "I'm on floor 152, I ran out of mp healing items and I'm almost out of mp, do I just keep going forward or should I bail for the night?" element, which is far more interesting than I can say for anything in FF13.
- Game flow is literally go down straight line and fight the whole game.
What other content in FF13 is there? Nothing. Except battles. I'd like to see you offer an argument that FF13 has something to offer other than battles. And for an rpg that bases its content solely on battles and dungeons, it can do a helluva lot better than that, any other dungeon crawler massacres FF13. FF13 is a very below average dungeon crawler.
To me, discussing FF13 isn't really a matter of discussing FF13 vs other FF games, but FF13 vs other rpgs and it barely satisfies.
I'm only mentioning these things in this FF13-2 thread because the only way I will ever consider buying FF13-2 is if they make an actual rpg out of it. Whether it's the dungeon crawl type or the adventure-y type. I don't care, so long as it's good and S-E should know that inciting interest in the sequel to the most ill received single player mainline FF pretty much ever with a pic that looks straight out the original FF13 is going to burn them. If anything, they should be telling us what's DIFFERENT rather than what hasn't changed.