warning:it better than has any right to be!
actually played through...my inner weeaboo is fulfilled for a good while.
I honestly was only going to give one route a chance, but says something that I ended up playing through all of them. worth at least a playthrough. the characters are actually really interesting, even if some are kinda overused anime tropes. also not sure why people were crying or anything...at its worst it's romance novel dreck, but is really fun when it's rolling. different authors for different routes mean some are much better than others.
Many people say the sex scenes are tasteful, and most um...kinda are....but having that shit on my screen was fucking embarrassing. There was an option for no matoor contentz, but I didn't want to miss anything. still, was kinda terrified my wife would walk in...some things you just can't explain.
I also like the story of the overall development...took a lot of dedication to make something so weird happen. really neat
game thing.
I'd say it's really worth a try...if I had to rate, I'd say:
Emi>Rin>Hanako>Lilly>Shizune.
spoiler (click to show/hide)
disclaimer: I actually fought my way through Tokimeki Memorial back in my high school days without knowing much japanese.