Bought it and played it a bit. It's "okay". By that I mean for someone like me who played Tony Hawk pretty casually its a decent nostalgia fix but its certainly not a great xbla title or anything. Something like Trials even though a completely different type of game shits all over this from a value proposition. It doesn't have enough tracks. No track creator. The physics are a bit wonky and you can get stuck in areas constantly dying because of it. And for the hardcore audience since it reverts back to the nature of Tony Hawk 1 that means it doesn't have endless combos which is what the Tony Hawk fans came to love.