Dragon Age 1 was really nice and full of promise for the future. So was Mass Effect 1. Both games screamed potential. But then instead of refining them into rpg's they watered them down to action games.
The shooting in Mass Effect is serviceable, but compared to real shooters it feels wonky.Having played 3 for 3 hours all the locales feel small, I was supposed to be fighting on the surface of a planet but I felt like I was running down corridors, the level design was just meh. There was more freedom in Tomb Raider then this.
Ironically SWOTR is the best game they made the last few years, and that's the one that gets shitted on the most. It is by all means at least an actual RPG with a big storyline.