Guild Wars disappointed me for the following reasons:
The COST of making pieces of armor you would wear for a few levels just blew me away.
Almost everyone sat in town dancing while half naked.
The enemy variety up to 20 levels in sucked hardcore.
Some of the quests...were STUPID hard, I mean fucking STUPID STUPID ASS HARD SONOFABITCH.
The fighting sounds and animations just didnt have the impact that say...the Warrior in WoW has. I need good combat feedback.
The death penalty was a shitty idea. So you cant complete a quest and you die, so they kill your stats making that quest even harder? BULLSHIT.
It is a very pretty game, and im sure if you find people to play with its fun. That makes pretty much anything fun, but you know what, a game shouldnt require other people for it to be fun. WoW is fun and I barely talk to anyone in the game. Its basically 3D Diablo if you want it to be.