Have you seen both of these movies already, or would you be going in a virgin (no andrex)?
Goodfellas is undoubtedly the better film. It really peaks in the first two acts though.
Petty complaint considering the amazing helicopter/cocaine paranoia montage at the end.
I would have thought a classic rock cornball like yourself would appreciate it. It goes like Jump Into the Fire ---> Rolling Stones #1 ---> The Who ---> Rolling Stones #2 ---> George Harrison --> Muddy Waters. That's not counting the Layla scene either.