http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1239424
Enderal is out well the German version is anyway.
I've played for about 5 hours. It's good for what it is, but I'm not going to keep playing. It's an entirely new world, new progression system, spells, skills, etc. but it still is very much Skyrim, and I really, really don't want to play more Skyrim.
Anyway, there are a few things I can sound off to (and be a surly curmudgeon about):
The writing is decent from what I've seen, as is the voice acting. It's on par with Bethesda's own efforts, anyway. Nothing really made me cringe, which is good enough for a total conversion.
The world itself is so cluttered at times that it's difficult to find your bearings, sometimes even the path in front of you. They don't know how to draw and lead your eye, something you only miss once it's gone.
For the interiors they tried to go for a more human scale, but it all just ends up feeling cramped. Curiously, exteriors are also cramped. There is such a dearth of flat land in the first area it seems as though they wanted to be the anti-Skyrim.
The first big city I got to had more loading screens seperating the quarters than even New Vegas. Paradoxically, this ends up making even Skyrim's glorified villages feel more like real cities. Yes, they're pretty empty, but there is also something resembling sprawl.
I have a sneaking suspicion that none of this is truly intended, that they simply couldn't get a grip on sightlines. The few vistas I've seen tanked my performance. This would explain why there are so many loading walls inside the city, too. Geometry overload, so, here's a loading wall. Shame.
One last thing: the bloom and HDR are really badly overdone (light sources in the vicinity made garlic and some wooden objects glow brighter than torches), but that can be dealt with using the "teofis" console command. It turns off a bunch of post-processing effects, at no real loss of visual fidelity that I could tell (or cared about, anyway). I think Skyrim had the same issue, though I don't remember it being this bad.
An A for effort, I suppose.