Dumb question, but was he really serious about that GafGold remark or is it just the running gag ?
SomethingAwful has 190k paid members (for a one time 10$ fee) while Neogaf has 170k free ones, realistically how many are willing to do the transition ? For a forum with not so robust servers & amateur moderation ? Anything over 12$ a year would seem obscenely expensive (well anything above 0 if you ask me, but heh). Not certain the profit margin on that would be worth the hassle.
Not that it matters anyway. GAF may be declining but I'm sure that cow got a few years worth of milk whatever the economic model, if you're willing to settle for making decent (not luxurious) revenue out of it.
HUGE

INCOMING
If we assume Evilore straight up rips off Lowtax:
I'd say it's a safe bet that 10% of those 170,000 will get a GAF Gold account. If you take the SA tenbux model, thats $170,000 right then and there.
I'd say it's a safe bet that 5% of them will likely buy another $10 upgrade per year, like an avatar or a signature. So that is another $85,000 a year of passive income.
Then there are about 1% of them that would be heavy users of GAF's crap, like buying signatures for others and other dumb crap. Assume they will spend $50 a year. That's another $85,000 a year in passive income.
Then there's about 0.1% of them that will be super heavy users because GAF is their life. They will think nothing of spending $100 a year on stupid shit. That's another $17,000 where Evilore does jack shit.
Overall, Evilore could be looking at a decent low six figure income by going the GAF Gold route, around $200k or so based off of my dumb estimates. Of course, this is no good for Evilore who assumed he would be a multimillionaire by the time he was 30 from GAF. Sorry but life isn't fair but he still gets to make great money by sitting on his ass, groping European women, and pretending to be an MMA expert in Thailand; not a bad deal overall for him. He can make good money for probably the next 10 years depending on the top 5% of gaffers who have more money than sense. There were plenty of gaffers who donated money to Amir0x's drug fund; it will be even easier to justify buying a signature and an avatar for $20.
tl;dr
