Looking at the Division thread on GAF people seem to be talking about the game so I'm going to.
There was very little content in the demo. Like one mission and a few side quests where you went to some spot in the world and just killed people. So in that sense there really wasn't a lot of judge.
That being said I think the formula of the game is still pretty obvious from the demo. It's a Tom Clancy game set in a destiny world. The controls are kinda clunky imo in the way that third person cover shooters often are but its no worse (or better) than typical. The graphics are fine although that 30 fps is a little hard to stomach after playing so many recent 60 fps multiplayer shooters.
You go do missions and get better guns with higher numbers just like Destiny or Borderlands but the fact that the world is grounded in a somewhat realistic world made that a little less interesting. Oh Boy I got an ak that does more damage. Maybe there is stuff in the game that gets like destiny or borderlands that are fairly unique but the trappings of the world is so mundane that it sucks some of the loot joy out of the experience for me.
It just felt very by the numbers. And while I don't like Destiny, that at least has a wow factor when you first start playing that this didn't have to me. I probably would like this more than what Destiny delivered though from a personal perspective. While this seems mundane it also seems like maybe fundamentally there is a clearer design and goal going on here.
There is a separate PVP area called the Dark Zone that basically like a multiplayer survival world where you can go in solo or with a group but its not about the story in that mode at all, its more about the players and trying to get loot and then extract the loot by helicopters which you have to defend. That part of the game actually seemed more interesting to me but there was also very little content due to alpha nature of what was given. It reminded me a bit of H1Z1 or Day Z in that its mainly driven by player interaction and how you deal with other people. So your experience will vary depending on the people who happen to be on at that time.
Overall, there is no way I would pay for it at full price. At discount maybe. It didn't strike me as a terrible game or anything. It just struck me as average.