>calls Jay-Z a lazy rapper >writes paragraphs praising Kanye West, saying that his lack of rapping ability doesn't matter classic himuro I don't understand why that's confusing. It's no different from 2pac. Jay has flow, but his lyrics generally do not jive with me. Kanye's flow tends to be bad but his lyrics would connect with me. When I say Jay z is a lazy rapper, I'm talking about the whole package. Not just rap
ability . It's the same thing with Common. Common is not the best rapper. Some of his songs would be better as poems than as songs. But if you give him the right beat, that nicca can cook. Rap ability is among the least important things for a rappers quality. Otherwise we'd listen to rappity rap rap shit.
Of the most important qualities of a rapper this is how I rate it:
1 is most important.
1. Message
2. Voice and intonation
3. Visual lyrics
4. Outward style (I.e. How they present themselves)
5. Production choice
6. Technical lyrics
7. Flow
Sometimes these qualities mix. Common will have a message while using using technical lyrics ("She know dairy so she say cheese to get bread"). Jay makes a lot of brag songs and lyrics but I've never heard him say anything as creative as Nas' "drank moet with Medusa gave her shotguns in hell with the spliff that I whiff and inhale". If you're gonna say you're all that, make it technical. Like the GOAT. Otherwise I will think you're just an egotistical busta looking fake bitch. Flow is probably the least important aspect of a rapper to me. At the same time, technical ability isn't the best either or otherwise I'd listen to Jadakiss - and I dont' listen to Jadakiss. But message will always trump anything else. Which is I like songs like Slim Thug's Chuuuch (what a bad song name).
VIDEO Before I listened to Never Let Me Down, I actually liked Jay-Z. Listening to it changed my entire perception of him. He went into a song with a beautiful message and rapped about himself. I hadn't listened to RD by that point, but that song sealed my opinion of him and I've felt the same ever since. My conclusion was that he was a bum rapper. Even if I admit RD is a classic, my thoughts still go back to Never Let Me Down and I can never shake that perception of him. Message is important.
Again, I brought up this example before but compare NY State of Mind to Shook Ones.
VIDEO VIDEO Given my ranking in the importance of rap skills above, which song would I prefer? I'm a highly visual person. If I can hear your song and make the song come to life like a movie? You're on my A list. For that message, intonation, visuality, and production are the most important aspects.
For me, Kanye fits my preferred idea of a rapper. Jay doesn't.