Is any of the Harry Potter shit after the original books worth it?

[CatsCatsCats]

Topic

[thisismyusername]

I mean if you're a super fan, the non-play ones  are alright if you're fine with children's books. But Cursed Child has been panned by most fans, AFAIK. I dropped the series after the 4th book.

[CatsCatsCats]

Definitely will need PD on this one, I know he majored in BBC but pretty sure he at least minored (no amirox) in HP

[Tasty]

Cursed Child is wacky fun that fits more as an extra-canon thing than Word of God™ as what happened after the Battle of Hogwarts.

Fantastic Beasts was OK, I expected a little more from it because I got myself hyped but it's a solid first entry in a new series of things. I'm hopeful the sequels will be a lot better now that the origin stuff is out of the way.

spoiler (click to show/hide)

Plus the promise of Dumbledore Jude Law vs. Grindelwald Johnny Depp is pretty crazy to imagine.

[close]

I think there's still a lot of potential for good world-building here and I trust Rowling to do it.

[Himu]

Real talk, Harry Potter wasn't good in hindsight and I've forgotten about everything related to those books since book 7.

[team filler]

Not enough incest to hold my attention

[TakingBackSunday]

Real talk, Harry Potter wasn't good in hindsight and I've forgotten about everything related to those books since book 7.

You fucking hate everything now

[dkdk]

Hell no

[Valkyrie]

Real talk, Harry Potter wasn't good in hindsight and I've forgotten about everything related to those books since book 7.

You hate literally everything and anything, your opinion isn't valid in this thread.

[Himu]

*dislikes a few things you like*

"You hate everything!"



Fucking nerds are pathetic. "You hate everything if you don't validate what I like!"

Real talk, Harry Potter wasn't good in hindsight and I've forgotten about everything related to those books since book 7.

You hate literally everything and anything, your opinion isn't valid in this thread.

I was a pretty big HP fan back in the day.

[Himu]

Where can I stream Fantastic Beasts so I can rep my house of choice Hufflepuff?

[CatsCatsCats]

Duly noted, will avoid

[Steve Contra]

The third one was good, and the fourth one was bad enough that I quit the whole thing.

[Himu]

Goblet was pretty bad

[demi]

Just play the GBC games they're awesome RPGs

[I'm a Puppy!]

Fantastic Beasts was a fun romp. It has potential. Let's see where they go with it.

[Himu]

is hufflepuff cool in beasts

[I'm a Puppy!]

Main character is hufflepuff as I remember.

[CatsCatsCats]

Thought it was entirely different houses

[I'm a Puppy!]

Thought it was entirely different houses

For the american characters it is. But the main character came from Hogwarts.

[Tasty]

They never even state the American houses in Beasts. There's like two mentions of Hogwarts and the American school anyways.

[CatsCatsCats]

Well 3:1 people agree it doesn't matter anyway

[Phoenix Dark]

I'm going to assume you're asking because you're looking to smash young pussy and need something to relate to them with. So the answer is yes.

[TVC15]

Just this (I got to attend a live performance of this):

https://soundcloud.com/themortifiedpodcast/62-naomi-harry-potter-fan-fiction

[Joe Molotov]

Just this (I got to attend a live performance of this):

https://soundcloud.com/themortifiedpodcast/62-naomi-harry-potter-fan-fiction

Better than any of the HP books.

[chronovore]

*dislikes a few things you like*

"You hate everything!"



Fucking nerds are pathetic. "You hate everything if you don't validate what I like!"

Real talk, Harry Potter wasn't good in hindsight and I've forgotten about everything related to those books since book 7.

You hate literally everything and anything, your opinion isn't valid in this thread.

I was a pretty big HP fan back in the day.

(Image removed from quote.)

I ain't gonna lie, and I'm not going to go back and re-read to verify, but my impression is that your last few original topic threads have been dumping on various things, espousing why popular opinion is wrong on some topic or another, or otherwise trying to make objective statements about subjective topics.

We don't always agree, and we don't have to, but I do feel you've been pretty negative lately.

[Tasty]

In terms of "all popular entertainment is trash " sure, Harry Potter falls under that. It's a book series for children and young adults. Within those parameters I think it's the best I've seen. Very endearingly-written characters, generally good pacing (outside Goblet/Order...), fresh-feeling and consistent world, and an interesting plot with various twists and turns.

[Tasty]

Goblet of Fire is amazing, wtf are people talking about?

Goblet the book was great.

Goblet the movie was probably the weakest one, though.

[Himu]

*dislikes a few things you like*

"You hate everything!"



Fucking nerds are pathetic. "You hate everything if you don't validate what I like!"

Real talk, Harry Potter wasn't good in hindsight and I've forgotten about everything related to those books since book 7.

You hate literally everything and anything, your opinion isn't valid in this thread.

I was a pretty big HP fan back in the day.

(Image removed from quote.)

I ain't gonna lie, and I'm not going to go back and re-read to verify, but my impression is that your last few original topic threads have been dumping on various things, espousing why popular opinion is wrong on some topic or another, or otherwise trying to make objective statements about subjective topics.

We don't always agree, and we don't have to, but I do feel you've been pretty negative lately.

I've been without hormones for months. Very few things to be positive about. I'm miserable. These fucks just have to deal with it.

[Tasty]

I've been without hormones for months. Very few things to be positive about. I'm miserable. These fucks just have to deal with it.

Then don't act surprised when people call you on it?

[Himu]

I'm not doing my best rn OK FUCK YOU

[chronovore]

I've been without hormones for months. Very few things to be positive about. I'm miserable. These fucks just have to deal with it.

Yeah, and I feel bad for you about that. You're still making choices in how you communicate.

I've been on the opposite side of it, where I posted mainly happy stuff when I was dealing with a pretty serious depression. FWIW, it didn't work for me.

Hope you get your scrips filled soon, and can regain balance.

[Himu]

Thanks. Currently dealing with heavy withdrawal symptoms.