Empire > New Hope > Return > TFA > TLJ > Rogue One > Ep3 > Ep1 > Ep2
close enough. i honestly don't remember shit from rogue one so i don't know where i'd rank it without a rewatch and that's not gonna happen.
Rogue One's got a really messy first act, a decent enough but mostly unremarkable second act, and a pretty good final act. Better than any of the PT, but wouldn't put it above any of the other Star Wars movies.
I disagree, mod. Ep1 and Ep3 are better simply by virtue of being competently made movies. That first act of Rogue One is a disaster, and there’s no way Disney didn’t know it when they shoved it out the door. It is poorly made. It is nearly narratively incoherent. If the whole movie was as bad as the first act, it would be way way way below Ep2 in quality.
The second act is also bad, but mainly because it’s boring and feels pointless because there was no build-up because the first act made as much sense as trying to read a word search puzzle as a paragraph.
The third act, though, is really good. Good enough to fool rubes into thinking they didn’t just witness a near-complete disaster.
Rogue One is terrible. The first act is (significantly) worse than anything in Ep2. I laugh when I see morons say it’s the best of the Disney films (which seems to happen pretty frequently). You can tell where there’s still lead paint by pinpointing their location on a map.