Bumping this thread because I can't get a decent AoE3 convo at all at GAF, they all seem to not like the game because it's too much like AoE2, which only makes sense if you are too much of a chicken/scrub to go online and play on ESO, or pirate all your PC games (like 75% of GAF does) so you didn't have that option.
The home city/card/deck mechanic is the best implementation of persistence in the genre and adds a TON to the game's longevity. I started playing this again last week (getting tired of Supreme Commander) and start goofing around with the Aztecs and Iroquois and got some basic strategies for them down. The Aztecs are a fun micro-heavy rusher that you can twist into an incredible boom build if you want, and the Iroquois seem totally overpowered with some of their cards. Both are good stuff and I am leveling home cities up, it's great fun, only problem is that the AI doesn't handle the rush nearly as well as they do a econ-heavy strategy.
What a great game. I see Rise of Legends is in this thread too, which gets even worse treatment from most people even though it plays better than RoN does. RoL skirmish is like my comfort food gaming nowadays-it's just so sublime and easy to relax and have fun with.