Who is going to say they don't value intelligence or loyalty in someone they choose as a mate rather than just someone to sleep with?
I value cleverness; I have both a wry and dry sense of humor that often throws booksmart, literal people for a loop, and I HIGHLY value the ability to keep up with my BS and roll with it.
Physically, well... I just love women. While I value athleticism and definitely drool over a strong flat stomach (and I like boobs and hips and legs and other bellwethers of femininity), mostly I value overall body proportion and how well one carries onself.
Living in NYC I'm really becoming disgusted by the oversexed/jaded and self-righteous/entitled attitude of women (or I guess people in general) here. There's only so many times I can handle some dysfunctional dilettante saying something along the lines of, "look I'm all about hooking up electrodes to my pussy and if you can't immediately sense that without my having to tell you--or if you're not an expert puss-shocker in the first place--I'm just not going to waste my time with you!"