These were all overrated games, at least once upon a time:
Tomb Raider (the first one, for PSX - wow at this game being ridiculously overhyped)
Battle Arena Toshinden (does anyone remember how overhyped this game was when it first came out? Never mind Virtua Fighter or Tekken, Toshinden was the 3D fighter fanboys were drooling over)
Final Fantasy VII (an utterly average game with an awful, awful translation, but it had CG movies, so waow)
NiGHTS (sorry guys, I love the Saturn, but wtf, this game was not great - you wanna talk underrated Saturn platformer, look at Burning Rangers instead)