I'm a sucker for anything with horror or occult elements, and have been known to endure pure shit like say, Ghost Ship, just because WOO HEY GHOSTS AND GORE.
In that spirit -- lulz -- I picked up Season 1 of the WB series Supernatural. It is a show about two pretty boys that go around hunting the fell forces of the occult because a demon killed their mom. Eventually, their dad shows up and they spend a fair few scenes grimacing at him (as he likewise grimaces back at them) because HEADSTRONG KIDS VERSUS AUTHORITARIAN DAD HOO HAW.
The Verdict: It's solid. I'll watch Season 2. (Also Season 2 has a flesh-eating killer clown in it, which I simply can't resist.)
The Good: Asylum episode; evil painting episode; dead kid in the lake episode; evil Nordic God turned scarecrow episode; a lot of the dialogue is sharp; classic rock tunes; Jensen Ackles and Jared Pada-whassisfuck are good actors despite their purpose as panty-moisteners for the pubescent set; BLACK '64 IMPALA.
The Bad: The "homages" to other horror movies -- The Ring, Carrie, The Shining et al aren't exactly subtle. It's one thing to reference as a sly wink to the audience; it's another thing to rip entire scenes and concepts wholesale. Oh, and the season finale rips ALIAS in the worst possible way. Obviously, somebody wanted their contract renewed *bad*. Lastly, the demons in the main arc aren't very scary when they aren't mutilating and incinerating peoples' loved ones, and they act cocky/funny. Boo.
The Lolz: RACIST DEATHTRUCK EPISODE -- starring KKKRISTINE! LULZ NERDS WITH WEBSITE ACCIDENTALLY CREATE EVIL UNDEAD HILLBILLY. WHY AREN'T THE BROTHERS WANTED IN EVERY STATE IN THE UNION?