Who cares either way? It was easily the most exciting play of the night. Best dunk comp since the 80's for me (although there were a few great ones in the 90's and the 2000 one was great), redemption big time for an event I had almost given up on. All 4 of Howard's dunks + the birthday cake dunk + Jomario Moon's first dunk were all flawless, with the Superman being the best. Sure, all 3 of Howard's other dunks were technically better, but none had the electricity of that one.